Move from Substack to Bento.

Export your Substack data, bring it into Bento, and rebuild what matters while Substack keeps sending. Cancel only when Bento is ready.

Import from SubstackMedium migration
CSVsubstack-contacts.csv12,400 rows, mapped
  • SubscribersImports directly
  • TagsImports directly
  • Custom fieldsImports directly
  • AutomationsRebuild in Bento
  • TemplatesRebuild in Bento
  • Commerce dataPartly moves
  • Email historyStays behind
3 of 7kinds of data import directly
  • Laravel News
  • Examine
  • Less Annoying CRM
  • Geocodio
  • Authority Hacker
  • HeadshotPro
  • QuickMail

Substack to Bento, at a glance.

From Bento's Substack migration guide. Still deciding? Read Bento vs Substack.

Medium

Migration difficulty

Varies by publication and paid subscription setup.

3 of 7

Kinds of data that import directly

The rest you rebuild in Bento or leave behind.

4

Export steps in Substack

Each one is written out below, with tips.

Your time depends on list size and how many flows you rebuild.

Four steps off Substack.

Substack keeps sending the whole time. You cancel only after Bento carries your mail.

  1. Export from Substack.

    4 steps in Substack, in the order below. Nothing changes for your subscribers yet.

    Export from Substack4 steps
    1. 1Log in to SubstackGo to Substack.com and access your dashboard.
    2. 2Export SubscribersGo to Subscribers, open the three-dot menu above the list, and export your subscriber CSV.
    3. 3Export ContentOpen Settings, choose Exports, and create a publication export containing posts, subscribers, and related statistics.
    4. 4Plan Paid Subscription MigrationCoordinate the billing cutover before disconnecting Stripe because Substack refunds readers and cancels paid subscriptions when paid subscriptions are turned off.
    Keep Substack sending while you export.
  2. Import into Bento.

    Upload the CSV and map each column to a Bento field or tag. Suppressions go in first, so nobody who left gets mail.

    PeopleImportssubstack-contacts.csv

    Start import
    CSV columnBento fieldType
    • emailEmailIdentity
    • first_nameFirst nameField
    • last_nameLast nameField
    • tagsTagsTags
    • planplanCustom field
    • last_order_atlast_order_atCustom field

    Rows

    12,400

    Before sending

    • Suppressions imported first
    • Unsubscribes kept unsubscribed
    • Tags created from the tags column
  3. Test, then switch.

    Authenticate your sending domain, rebuild the flow that earns the most, and send a seed test while Substack keeps sending.

    Launch checklist4 of 5
    • Sending domain authenticated in Bento
    • Suppressions moved from Substack
    • Seed test sent and checked
    • Highest-revenue flow rebuilt and tested
    • Switch sending to BentoNext
    Warm up with your most engaged subscribers first.
  4. Cancel Substack last.

    Warm up with your most engaged subscribers, move the rest of your sending, and cancel Substack only once Bento carries it.

    Sending, by phase
    PhaseSubstackBento
    1. ExportSendingNot yet
    2. ImportSendingImporting
    3. Rebuild and testSendingTesting
    4. Warm upSendingWarming
    5. Cancel SubstackOffSending
    No gap in sending at any phase.

Export your Substack data.

Run these in Substack before you change anything there. Keep the files somewhere safe until Bento is sending.

  1. 1

    Log in to Substack

    Go to Substack.com and access your dashboard.

  2. 2

    Export Subscribers

    Go to Subscribers, open the three-dot menu above the list, and export your subscriber CSV.

  3. 3

    Export Content

    Open Settings, choose Exports, and create a publication export containing posts, subscribers, and related statistics.

  4. 4

    Plan Paid Subscription Migration

    Coordinate the billing cutover before disconnecting Stripe because Substack refunds readers and cancels paid subscriptions when paid subscriptions are turned off.

What comes with you.

3 of 7 kinds of data import directly. The rest you rebuild in Bento or leave behind.

Your import checklist

Import from Substack3 of 7 direct
  • SubscribersImports directly
  • TagsImports directly
  • Custom fieldsImports directly
  • AutomationsRebuild in Bento
  • TemplatesRebuild in Bento
  • Commerce dataPartly moves
  • Email historyStays behind

Same ideas, new names

SubstackBento
  • SubscriberPersonIndividual contact
  • Free SubscriberPerson with tagTag for subscription type
  • Paid SubscriberPerson with tagTag for subscription type
  • PostBroadcastEmail sends

Before you cancel Substack

  • Choose a separate website or publishing platform for the public archive
  • Confirm the paid subscription cutover with Substack support and the destination billing provider
  • Notes, recommendations, followers, and publication Chat do not transfer
  • Disconnecting Stripe in Substack refunds readers and cancels paid subscriptions

Get a person to plan the move.

Tell us your current provider, list size, and what you need to keep. We map the order to move things and review your domain setup before you send.

A migration request

you@example.comMigration quote

We are on Substack with 12,400 contacts. We need to keep subscribers, tags, and suppressions.

Bento teamReplied

Thanks. Start with suppressions, then your list, then the flows that make money. We can review your domain setup before you send.

Teams switch for deliverability and stay for the support.

“Moving to Bento was the best thing I ever did for my list and its profitability”
Iliane L.G2
“I love how easy it is to use to design SaaS emailing sequences. You can also see rapidly which campaigns are the money makers. But what I love the most is undoubtedly the deliverability that you have once you've set up custom domain tracking”
Arnaud B.G2
“The support and community within Bento is hands down the best I've ever seen from any company, ever.”
Luke J.G2

Questions about leaving Substack.

Will I lose my Substack subscribers when I switch?
Substack lets you export subscribers as CSV and posts with related statistics in a publication export. Full subscriber names are not currently included in the list export. Paid billing does not transfer automatically, so plan that cutover separately.
Can I still do paid newsletters with Bento?
Yes, with an external publishing and billing setup. Send payment or membership events from Stripe or your application into Bento, then use fields, tags, and segments to message each tier. Bento does not host the paywall or process the subscription.
What about the Substack network and discovery?
Bento has no equivalent to Substack's recommendations, Notes, restacks, reader app, or publication search. Plan a separate acquisition strategy and expect those network relationships to remain on Substack.
Where do I host my content after leaving Substack?
Bento focuses on email. For content hosting, use your own website, Ghost, or a similar publishing platform. Your emails still come from you, just with more automation power behind them.
How does Bento's pricing compare to Substack?
Substack charges 10% of each paid transaction plus Stripe fees. Bento Marketing Platform is $29 per month for up to 5,000 Active Users, then tiered pricing starts at $0.01 per additional Active User. Compare that bill with the publishing and billing tools needed outside Bento.
Will switching hurt my deliverability?
Inbox placement can change after any provider move. Preserve consent and suppressions, authenticate the sending domain, and increase volume carefully. Bento includes reputation monitoring, authentication help, batching controls, and deliverability support.
Will there be downtime?
No. Keep Substack running while you import, test, authenticate your sending domain, and warm up. Once Bento is ready, move your sending and phase out Substack.
Can the Bento team help if I get stuck?
Yes. The team can review your current setup, help you decide what to move first, and advise on deliverability, data mapping, and launch order.

Other migration guides.

Start your move from Substack.

Free for 30 days. We help you move your lists, flows, and templates.