the Bento growth platform

The Secret Psychology Behind Your Shopping Cart: Cognitive Biases Unveiled

Thoughts by Alyssa Jean • Writer Bento

Ever found yourself marveling at how a simple email nudged you into buying something you didn't even know you wanted? It's not magic; it's psychology at play. Welcome to the intriguing world of cognitive biases, the brain's little shortcuts that influence our decisions, especially in the digital marketplace of email marketing. If you're navigating the e-commerce or email marketing universe, you're about to discover how these biases can be your best friends.

Anchoring Bias: First Impressions Stick

Remember the last time a headline caught your eye, and suddenly, you found everything else in the article more compelling? That's anchoring bias for you—the tendency to rely heavily on the first piece of information we encounter.

In Email Marketing: Make a splash with your opening act. Highlight a premium product or an unbeatable offer right at the start. This sets the tone, making all subsequent offerings appear even more attractive. It's like telling a story where the opening line ensures the reader can't help but read on. For instance, starting an email with "Our most luxurious skincare line yet..." primes readers to view the following products as especially desirable.

Bandwagon Effect: Everyone's Invited to the Party

The allure of belonging can't be underestimated. The bandwagon effect leverages our desire to be part of the majority, to follow the crowd.

In Email Marketing: Use social proof to your advantage. Customer reviews, testimonials, or even a simple "best-seller" badge next to products can significantly sway decision-making. It's akin to saying, "See how many are already enjoying this? You're missing out!" This method doesn't just validate the product's worth; it creates a sense of community and belonging. Picture an email filled with happy faces and rave reviews, subtly inviting the reader to join the happy customer club.

Scarcity Bias: The Now-or-Never Approach

Why do limited editions excite us so much? Scarcity bias is at work, making us yearn for things that seem rare or fleeting.

In Email Marketing: Craft messages that highlight exclusivity and urgency. Phrases like "Limited offer" or "Only a few left!" can trigger an immediate response. This tactic transforms an ordinary product into a coveted treasure, much like a limited-time invitation to an exclusive event. Imagine an email that reads, "Exclusive preview for our VIP subscribers only," and watch the click-through rates soar.

Loss Aversion: Dodging the Miss-Out Misery

The fear of losing out can often outweigh the joy of gaining. That's loss aversion—our tendency to go to great lengths to avoid missing out.

In Email Marketing: Frame your campaigns to spotlight what's at stake. Instead of just highlighting the benefits, emphasize what your customers stand to lose if they don't act. An email that says, "Last chance to enjoy 20% off!" plays on the natural instinct to avoid loss, making the offer hard to ignore.

Confirmation Bias: The "I Knew It!" Feeling

We love it when new information confirms our existing beliefs. Confirmation bias is all about seeking and prioritizing information that aligns with our previous choices or beliefs.

In Email Marketing: Send personalized content that resonates with the recipient's past interactions or purchases. This could mean recommending products similar to those they've bought before or content that aligns with their interests. It's like saying, "Since you loved X, you're going to adore Y!" This not only makes the email more relevant but also reinforces the customer's belief that they're making the right choices.

Choice-Supportive Bias: Post-Purchase Bliss

Ever rationalized a purchase by focusing only on its positives? That's choice-supportive bias in action, where we justify our decisions by overlooking any flaws.

In Email Marketing: Follow up after a purchase with messages that validate and celebrate the customer's choice. Share tips on how to get the most out of the product, related items, or simply a note that says, "You've made a fantastic choice!" This enhances satisfaction and loyalty, making the customer feel confident and happy about their decision.


By diving into the psychology of cognitive biases, email marketers can craft strategies that not only captivate and convert but also create a richer, more engaging customer experience. It’s about understanding the subtle forces that guide our decisions and using them to build meaningful, lasting relationships with your audience. So, the next time you're drafting an email campaign, remember these insights. You're not just selling a product; you're engaging with the human psyche, making every email an opportunity to connect, persuade, and delight.